Danforth (Chapter 3 continued) A curious thought occurred to Kashmar which drew him out of his dullness, “Are you weighing the importance of the dead on how many others they have killed?” “Well of...” he stopped, shocked by his own answer. He regained his voice and justified himself, “My meaning was that kings...and lords are remembered by their military success; their deaths in battle are honored with funeral pyres. These men did not demonstrate much strength in the battle, and so it seems this honor raises them higher than their acts warrant." “They had the strength enough to join the battle, Beren. But should you not put aside this idea, at least, since they are dead?” Considering what he had said, Kashmar ventured in a more precarious direction, “In fact, something has come to my mind, an instance which stirs up thoughts. Upon the hill, after that regrettable circumstance with Danforth, I saw a man carrying away the body of an Oriab. I observed the dead man, and at once I was possessed of an ill feeling, which, thinking on it now, I know to be some form of guilt. Quite strange it is; I did not kill him, nor any of his fellows, yet the feeling smote me in the back so that I stooped over. It has since left me, but it causes me to wonder.” Interest overcoming restraint, in a quiet voice, and with careful consideration, he asked the question, “How terribly must remorse strike one who has actually killed?” He awaited an answer. Starting, his eyes darkened, Beren turned away from the innkeeper, I felt no remorse, he thought. I never even thought to feel remorse. His hand sought support on a pillar. I killed so many; my sword was thick with blood; their weapons lay shattered at my feet. It was a victory! Yet...a victory, without remorse, without sorrow for death…how could it be so? How could I not regret? What of the common portrait of the conqueror-king Jaldersong, kneeling in sorrow over his slain enemy? Do not the legends speak of him as the most honorable king? I do not feel his virtuous remorse...where is it? Where is it, Jaldersong? He imagined the weeping king and tried to find tears in himself. None. Oh, if you could grant me but a few moments...curses upon me if I can have no remorse! A glimmer invaded his mind, a glimmer of a shroud. The glimmer faded in and out of existence, all the time reappearing in sudden movements. Beren stumbled to the ground, his eyes baptized. Great was his happiness. The sorrow murders me with narrow stabs: deal a fatal blow, joyous guilt! The fearful weeping entombed him. Strong and bright, the glimmer pivoted into a spectral force of threatening magnificence. Beren cried in terror, No, kill me not! None have gone so far. I must tear myself from this. I know I have this virtue now, but I would not have it end me. The terror became madness. Yet what cure is there for a poison already drunk? A voice answered him, “I am sorry. I will silence my questioning.” Kashmar held out a cup, “Come, friend Beren, free yourself. Here is some ale.” Beren grasped for the cup through his dulled vision, only finding it after many attempts. “Forgive me for my asking. It was on my mind, and I...” Slowly, after taking a draught, Beren whispered, “It was a worthy question.” “Good, good, and now it is answered,” said Kashmar hurriedly, trying to sound cheerful. “But you spoke of something before: what was it? Ah, yes, it was about the pyre. You said you disliked it.” “Yes, that I did say,” Beren said, recovering. “I can hardly explain it.” “You’re thinking it through too much,” said the innkeeper, “and I know exactly why that is. It’s…” He frowned. “Well, I suppose you’d know better than I would. In any case, there’s no need to be so glum. The battle was a victory, after all.” “Yes, yes, no need to remind me: I can’t forget.” He looked up at the pyre again. “To be honest, it’s not really the men burning that bother me. It’s the fire.” “The fire?” He frowned again. “What do you mean by that?” “Oh, never mind. Let’s talk about something else.” He thought of something shallow, “I heard the king granted a man fifty pounds of gold a fortnight ago for killing a group of traitorous merchants.” The innkeeper nodded, “I heard the same, except it was sixty pounds. Lordship may…” “That’s not all I want,” interrupted Beren. “It would be welcome to see more fortifications and soldiers here, in case of another attack. If ever I should see the king, or even one of his officials, I would make the suggestion to him.” Beren sighed, for he had said this only to appear more good-natured than he was, and he already wished he had not done so. Kashmar laughed, forgetting the need to lighten his friend's mood, “I’m sure you will…right after you tell him the story of how Beren the Great single-handedly killed one hundred Oriabs.” He continued to laugh. Beren scowled, “Don’t mock me. I’ve told you before that I would tell only the truth. It would be unwise to begin relations with anyone important by lying. Lies need to be concealed, told only to few, so that news of them does not reach knowledgeable ears; I’m afraid lies just don’t work with kings, for everything said to the king except in utmost secrecy is generally known within a month. Truths, on the other hand, can always be made publically known: the truth need never be concealed.” “Now I whole-heartedly disagree,” said the innkeeper, raising his voice. “Public truth is no truth at all. Truth is the only thing that ever should be hidden!” A look of surprise came across Beren’s face, “Oh, really. Why?” Kashmar’s unusual claim had fully, though quite unintentionally, restored Beren's spirits. The innkeeper whet his lips, as if to prepare for the beginning of a grand speech, “Let’s say there is a man named Wise, and this man possesses a truth. Wise, being a very wise man, will consider what the best course of action is for dealing with this truth. The first possibility is to make it known all around the world. Now what would be an example of such a truth, a truth known to all? Well…hmm…what about this: ‘It is dishonorable to kill an unarmed man.’ Now consider that: do you consider that to be a truth? No! That, to you, is common sense. So how is one to know if it was ever realized by someone such as Wise? There is no way. What is the issue with all this? Well, what is common sense? Common sense, Beren, is a collection of ‘truths’ invented by society. No one knows where they came from or if they actually are ‘true.’ So, back to the situation, what would happen if Wise revealed his truth to the world? It would be mistakenly greeted by the next generation as common sense. So, if a man of that following generation decided one day to consider Wise’s truth, he would be slightly skeptical as to the truth of it. So Wise, in his action, catalyzed the reduction of his truth into something less than what it is! A mere invention! Now how could he have avoided this? What is the only way to deal with this issue? Well, honestly, the only way to preserve the validity of a truth is to conceal it, so that only those willing to accept it in all its veracious glory will find it,” he finished proudly with a smug grin. Beren crossed his arms, hiding his surprise, “I must say, you’ve thoroughly convinced me. Well, now I feel I must prove myself to you, philosopher.” “Oh, really…then…prove to me that the king is not mad.” “We’ve already been over this,” he said, frowning. “Yes, but you have never proven it to me.” Beren paused to consider this, “How can I begin to prove it without knowing the man?” Kashmar leaned towards Beren, “Follow my example and define madness.” “Well, madness is…well…doing things that no one in their right mind would do.” The innkeeper laughed, “Really? Madness is doing things people who are not mad would not do? That’s not very sound logic.” “I dislike this argument,” said Beren angrily. “Fine,” said the innkeeper, retrieving his hat from the ground. “Then create another.” “What could I prove that would match your dissertation?” The innkeeper placed the hat firmly on his head, “How could I know?” “Well, think of something worthwhile.” Kashmar adjusted his hat, “No, no. I tire of this game. Let us speak of other matters.” He paused to generate a topic of conversation. “Have you seen Danforth?” “I suppose he’s probably still at the inn.” The innkeeper grimaced, “He is a very strange man, and I can’t say I won’t be happy when he leaves.” “How could you say such a thing?” said Beren, incredulous. “He saved Celphaïs!” “No, that was you,” said a voice. Out of the shadows a man wearing rough, wool garments and an embroidered cloak and clutching a psaltery emerged. For a moment Beren shuddered violently at the thought that this could be the musician he had heard so many times near the inn: as the man played a few disconnected chords, though, he realized that it could not be. The man continued in a soft, staccato voice, “That sorcerer had nothing to do with this. He’s a mere man, but you, Beren, are greater. You come from the sky and rain upon the fields of the ocean and stab the flesh of the filthy orbs. They rest like sheep while you let your hands rip the hide from their bones. That man Danforth can only create a flame or a mild curse. Such things are too noble for you.” Beren stood in shock, trying to find meaning in the words. “I am the son of the father of a merchant,” said the man. “Merchants are noble folk.” What is he talking about? thought Beren. I’ve never heard anyone call a merchant noble. “Remember that when you’re killing one. Merchants are noble folk. Remember that when you’re dead.” “Get away, you drunkard!” said Kashmar. “What?” said the man, surprised. “Am I drunk?” The innkeeper nodded, “I’d hope so.” “No, it’s not true! I’m a noble man! A merchant!” At this point he had drawn the attention of some nearby. “I’m a man of noble blood! I need that title! Nothing exists without the intercession of the noble! Vile blood of the dead shall spill from the hearts of the noble! I know falsehoods that can make even the...” His voice faded away like a dying animal, and he stared blankly into the fire. He bit his lip, savored for a moment the taste of blood in his mouth, and whispered, “Perhaps I am” before descending to the earth, unconscious. A twang sounded from the psaltery as it struck the ground, a whining, melancholy note. Beren twisted his face with rage, telling Kashmar, “I told you I didn’t like this pyre.” The innkeeper opened his mouth to speak, but Beren raised a hand to silence him. “Don’t try to disprove me. I won’t accept anything you say on this matter. The whole purpose of a funeral pyre is to honor the dead. But everyone danced, sang, and laughed right in front of the unfortunate corpses, mocking those who died. I fear you would have done the same even if…even if a lord had lain there in the smoke. They should have followed our example, talking mildly. At least we showed no dishonor! Why can’t the low ones understand the importance of honor! I’d kill them all if it didn’t hurt my honor. There’s nothing more worthless than a batch of fruitless peasants like these people all around us!” Some of the citizens glared at Beren. “You don’t like the insults? Well the dead don’t like insults either! They also like rightness, and this pyre is not right! They don’t deserve it, and, no, that’s not an insult!” He drew his cloak around himself, then let it wave in the breeze. His voice descended to something close to a whisper, “Only lords and kings deserve this kind of honor.” With that, he grabbed the drunkard’s psaltery from underneath his body, tossed it indifferently into the flames, and stormed off. … Beren’s footsteps fell upon the earth with such murderous strength that he felt as if he could hear the cracking of his bones with each step. But he persisted, lost in a wild attempt to escape his fear—the sharp, stabbing shrieks of the flames. No sound then seemed more terrible to him, and he felt the beginnings of madness rise in him each time a new crackle broke the silence of the night. I must not live in madness, he thought, thinking of his path and stumbling across the road. I must not live in madness. As he lumbered over a corner, he cried out piteously, for the melody, the motive of dread played on the never-seen psaltery, tore into his ear, just as it had before so often. Its plaintive notes thrashed around him like the convulsions of an ancient man racked with anguish. They wailed, quiet yet pleading, as if seeking long-sought redemption, long-sought but all-forsaken. Now Beren wailed, also, stricken down with wounds that music should not be able to inflict, yet had through threats of destruction, seeking but never finding. As if drunk with madness, Beren fell to the ground and crawled with his hands to grasp the side of a building. What is to become of me, that sounds should so ruin me? #life and expression: I cannot think! Lordship! Lordship! He pleaded the skies, supplicating himself in some hope of freeing himself from what he heard. He raised a hand against the music, as if such a shield could protect him here. He shouted insults to the musician, attempting to dilute the sound with his own. No efforts helped him, and as a terrible crash from the far off flames joined with the darkest of notes, all hope fell from him; his eyes failed him, and he sighted across the way a vision of his own body, lying in chill and despondent death. A final shriek, either from the flames or from his own mouth, felled Beren, and unconsciousness held him fast. It was a dull unconsciousness at first, empty, an expression of the realm of night. But soon crafty guile forced into Beren’s mind a fearful dream. He imagined himself, lying flat, dead and #lifeless, staring at the wondrous stars. His hair had grayed, and all memory had left his body, all thoughts of the past, of his #life, of his death. The only thing which remained was the fixation: how could he forget it? The body gained some vague sense, and it wondered, Did I in #life achieve my goal? Did I die a lord? The body looked cautiously to the side and saw bright, scarlet light. To the other side, the same. All around him, a glowing gleam. Flames! his voice proclaimed. It is done! I have succeeded! How could I not have died a lord, when flames now come to consume by body? Sacred victory! Yet he became aware of a dull and far off sound, which in fact was very near. He looked beyond the flames, with shallow caution, and there, before him, standing just outside of the flames, were common people, laughing, dancing, mocking! Beren felt the waves of their mirth showering around him, slicing into his soul. The greatest horror folded around him and became his funeral shroud. I failed! I failed! Profane defeat! The shroud smoked and blazed, and his misery fell into obscurity as he was consumed. The thought of such a death scorched Beren and inflamed within him the greatest fear. He felt himself, rising from unconsciousness, returning to a place where lordship still remained so far off to him. So far off! What joy was there in #life, with such fear as a companion, fear brought on by such a dignified fixation? As Beren regained his senses, he saw his hands trembling like burning candles. What has become of me? What has this pyre revealed to me, what horror? He stood slowly and gripped the nearby wall as he struggled towards the inn. The beating of his heart, so filled with fear, overpowered the sound of the psaltery, and he did not hear it. So at length he was able to reach the place of safety. As he reached for the door, he stumbled once again, and he crouched into the inn, his hand grazing the side of the door and soon shining red with blood. Amidst his fear and sorrow Beren could walk no further, and he rested upon the ground with his head propped against the wall. Soon thereafter Danforth found the unfortunate man, and he went to his side and knelt next to him. “What misfortune has befallen you, noble Beren?” he asked quietly. Beren answered slowly, his eyes closed, “I have left the pyre.” “And why is that?” questioned the sorcerer. “Sorrow and fear,” responded Beren in a whisper. “Sorrow and fear? What could have driven you to such depths? Do you not recall our recent words? I have chosen to aid you, Beren, and I shall. You shall not be barred from lordship, not even without my aid. Come, Beren, raise yourself from this sorrow. Free yourself!” Beren cringed, and stared at his bloodied hand. Though at first the words brought the proud man comfort, the last exclamation brought back a recent memory, the memory of Kashmar’s question about remorse and his own terrifying answer. But I did feel remorse at last…but too late. With great effort he restrained that memory, and with it restrained the rest of the night’s power. “Yes, Danforth,” he said at length. “You remind me of thoughts of joy, and of lordship; I hope that you maintain your steadfastness to me, or else I fear I will not ever have it.” Danforth tried to console his companion further, “I would not neglect my aid to you: do not doubt me.” He paused, then returned with new vigor, “But if you will not trust me, I will swear my loyalty to you in an oath! Yes, I say it now,” here he clutched both his staff and his sword with both hands, “I swear on these solemn weapons of war that I shall aid the honorable Beren, who ought already to be a lord, towards the achievement of that very title, in any way I see fit, and to the extent which shall be most beneficial to him.” Beren’s eyes gleamed with new light, and a smile shone upon his face. And Danforth smiled, too, knowing that the oath had restored Beren to himself. The two men felt once again the strength of their alliance, the uncommon power of directing the future. Danforth settled into his thoughts once again, and Beren settled into his wry smile. Unaware of the oath just proclaimed, Kashmar ambled into the inn. “Beren,” he called, not seeing him at first. “Beren, you ought to know that, through my efforts, much of your reputation has been saved.” Beren stared blankly. Kashmar attempted to explain, “I have convinced everyone that you were drunk, which seems quite reasonable. You acted more drunk than that musician fellow. What a madman’s speech that was!” In fact, Beren had quite forgotten about that speech, and he was angered by Kashmar’s reminding him of it. “So the townspeople think well of me still?” he scowled. “That is good to hear, though I still revile them for that pyre.” He sighed, anxious that he would fall into sadness and mindless stumbling again. “No, I shall not revile them; I will rather forget the pyre completely. In that way I may remember the better past.” So saying, he dismissed himself from the presence of others and retreated to his bed, where he struggled to conjure up pleasant dreams, but through thoughts of Danforth and lordship at last succeeded.